The City's posted agenda for this meeting held cover memos only. These attachments were released by public records request: requested Oct 12, 2026, delivered Oct 19, 2026.
Speaker expressed support for the city incorporating climate resiliency into operations, citing unprecedented climate disasters, and urged the city to expand EV programs and other climate-resilient infrastructure.
Speaker identified as an environmental researcher with University of Florida experience in sub-Saharan agricultural strategy.
Speaker presented findings from a public records request for text messages around the time of the mayor's radio appearance discussing affordable housing.
Speaker raised concerns about a text indicating the mayor had a 'warm meeting' with Ryanair (the largest landowner in the county) and an engineering company, that philosophies were shared, and that the mayor announced formation of a task force he would manage.
Speaker also referenced a radio station comment about bonding out 'Elite' to develop Town Center, and requested the mayor disclose communications with other council members, citing Florida Sunshine Law concerns.
Council Member Heighter read the proclamation designating October 2023 as National Domestic Violence Awareness Month.
Tricia Coney, CEO of the Family Life Center (Flagler County's only certified DV shelter), reported providing over 567,000 hours of services and noted the shelter operated at 129% capacity.
Candice Wilke, DV Services Coordinator, announced October events including a half-day conference on October 20 at Daytona State College Palm Coast Campus.
The Blue Knights Law Enforcement Motorcycle Group Chapter 22 presented a $1,000 check to the Family Life Center.
Council appointed six individuals to the Code Enforcement Board.
Genero Arcamone, Larry Pulos, and Charles Dean Roberts were reappointed to existing seats (Roberts required a 4/5 vote as a multi-term member and received 4 votes); Larry Stancil was appointed to the seat vacated by Mr.
Sullivan (who declined reappointment), receiving 3 of 5 votes over Merit Zuka; Jonathan Andrachek and Merit Zuka were then appointed as the two alternate members by unanimous motion.
The 5th Amendment to the Palm Coast Park Master Planned Development Agreement (Application No.
5276) was continued at the applicant's request.
Staff indicated the item will be re-advertised when it is ready to return; it was not read into the record.
The voluntary annexation ordinance for approximately 62.1 acres on the east side of Old Kings Road (Old Kings Village, Application No.
5362) was approved 5-0.
The applicant's representative Michael Chimento presented a voluntary agreement memorializing commitments including a 6-foot fence and landscape buffer along the eastern boundary adjacent to Polo Club West.
Three Polo Club West residents spoke, requesting more time and more specific deliverables before annexation, particularly regarding buffer cross-sections and the loss of existing PUD protections.
Council acknowledged the concerns and directed staff to identify specific community requests and communicate them to the developer before the upcoming rezoning and comp plan amendment.
First reading of an ordinance amending the Future Land Use Map for the 375+/- acre Cascades planning area (Application No.
5109) from Flagler County designations of Residential Low Density/Rural Estate and Conservation to City of Palm Coast designations of Residential and Conservation, with a site-specific policy capping development at 850 dwelling units.
Staff reported the planning board recommended approval 4-1 in August.
Council Member Pontieri voted against, citing concerns about doubling density, infrastructure strain, quality-of-life impacts on existing residents, and the pattern of annexing county land and then increasing density.
First reading of the Cascades Rezoning ordinance (Application No.
5107) rezoning 375 acres from Flagler County PUD and New Rural Communities designations to City of Palm Coast SFR-1, MFR-2, and Preservation zoning districts.
The applicant modified the proposal since the planning board hearing to shift multi-family areas eastward and commit to 150-foot building setbacks from the drainage easement.
Several residents of Seminole Woods Boulevard spoke against the multi-family component, citing concerns about building height, loss of privacy, traffic, and property values.
Council Member Pontieri voted against for the same density/quality-of-life reasons.
Council directed staff and the developer to meet with residents before the second reading.
Speaker requested permission to withhold comments on the Cascades project until after the council presentation, noting that what was shown at the Planning Commission differed from what would be presented, and residents wanted to see the current plan first.
Speaker, a resident since 2011 whose home appears on the Cascades project map, expressed concern about traffic safety on Seminole Woods Boulevard, citing two accidents in three weeks at the nearby bus stop.
Speaker stated children cannot safely ride bikes or run near the road currently, and worried about how increased traffic from the development would worsen the situation.
Speaker, a resident on Slipper Orchid Trail one street back from Seminole Woods Boulevard, stated the Planning Commission changed the multi-family building height limit from 35 to 60 feet and questioned whether 16-foot trees in front would adequately screen a 60-foot building.
Requested the height limit be reduced back to 35 feet for multi-family buildings in the project.
Speaker, resident at One Slipper Orchid Trail, stated her home would be directly adjacent to the multi-family area without a buffer on the north side.
Reported that at the community meeting residents were told the development would include townhouses, not apartments, but the current proposal includes apartments.
Stated she and other residents never received required notification letters.
Raised concerns about traffic, crime, property values, flood systems, school overcrowding, and privacy.
Requested setbacks of 150-200 feet and cited Integra Woods as a model for how multi-family should be screened.
Speaker, a Connecticut resident who owns property in Palm Coast for 13 years, stated he purchased in Palm Coast to avoid multi-family density similar to Connecticut.
Stated opposition to multi-family development across the street from his home, and requested to be notified when multi-family construction begins so he can list his property for sale.
Speaker raised questions about whether the city's water supply is adequate to support all currently approved and pending development.
Speaker questioned whether Palm Coast's municipal water utility could meet Public Utilities Commission standards if independently reviewed, and asked the council to commission a third-party review of water capacity and protection of west-side well sites.
First reading of amendments to the Special Event Ordinance (Chapter 28, Article 2) was approved unanimously.
Staff presented two updates made since the prior week's workshop: clarifying 'site plan' language to include 'event layout, traffic flow and parking,' and adding exemptions to the 180-day advance notice requirement for events not meeting the definition threshold and for recurring events with an approved site plan on file.
No public comment was received.
George Myers (Stormwater Operations Manager) and FIND Commissioner Randy Stapleford presented results of the September 9, 2023 Intracoastal Waterway Cleanup.
193 volunteers collected 1,881 pounds of trash.
Girl Scout Troop 2413 collected the most trash (1,100 lbs), Christopher and Sophia Harrison were top individual collectors (80 lbs), and Carolyn Whitney won most unique find (a concrete telephone line marker).
This year's mascot was 'Torpedo the Osprey.' FIND has provided over $80,000 in grant funding over 16 years of partnership.
A resolution approving the 2023 FIND Grant agreement for one waterway cleanup event was read into the record and approved unanimously without public comment.
The resolution authorizes the City Manager to execute the grant agreement with the Florida Inland Navigation District.
Resolution approving the Legacy at Palm Coast Technical Site Plan Tier 3 (Application No.
5304) for a 300-unit apartment community on approximately 27 acres in Town Center (Track 18a), developed by Landmark Communities.
Buildings are 3-4 stories.
The planning board recommended approval 5-0 in August.
A parking flexibility reduction of 7 spaces (520 provided vs.
527 required) was supported by staff.
The project includes a northbound left-turn lane on Town Center Boulevard at Lake Avenue.
Approved unanimously with no public comment.
Resolution approving the Retreat at Town Center Phase One Final Plat (Application No.
5301) for 66 single-family residential lots on 13 tracts within 39.74 acres of Town Center.
This is the final ministerial step in the subdivision process; most infrastructure is in place and a performance bond of $252,591.79 has been received for remaining work.
The planning board approved the subdivision master plan in April 2021.
No public comment.
Approved unanimously.
Resolution approving an engineering construction contract with Hazen Construction for the Willow Woods A1A Water Main Extension, serving approximately 20 existing homes on the North Peninsula within the city's utility service territory but outside city limits.
The approximately $980,000 contract plus contingency is fully funded by ARPA grant funds through an ILA with Flagler County.
No public comment.
Approved unanimously.
Consent item approving vacation of easements for property at 5622 State Highway 100 E (Parcel IDs 08-12-31-4300-00000-0010 and -0020), owned by SKUSA Palm Coast LLC.
Approved as part of the consent agenda.
Consent item approving a contract with Aquatic Management Plus, LLC for weed control of the freshwater stormwater drainage system.
Council Member Pontieri noted she had received satisfactory staff follow-up on the rationale for price increases and was awaiting data on the success rate of carp use.
Approved as part of the consent agenda.
Consent item approving additional funding for expenses related to Peavy Grade Roadway Design and Maintenance Operation Center.
Approved as part of the consent agenda.
Consent item approving piggybacking the City of Coconut Creek contract with Cityscape Consulting, Inc. for wireless communication permit review pricing.
Approved as part of the consent agenda.
Consent item approving a Master Service Agreement with Roadtek, LLC for asphalt and concrete repair services.
Approved as part of the consent agenda.
Consent item approving piggybacking the Sourcewell State of Minnesota contract with WESCO Distribution, Inc.
(Anixter) for purchase of miscellaneous electrical supplies as needed.
Approved as part of the consent agenda.
Consent item approving a sole source agreement with Empire Pipe & Supply, Inc. for purchase of water meters.
Approved as part of the consent agenda.
Speaker challenged the City Attorney's Sunshine Law interpretation regarding the mayor-to-Heighter email exchange, suggesting the council consult outside counsel Bill Richman.
Speaker also raised concerns about the adequacy of Palm Coast's water utility capacity relative to development approvals, and referenced the phenomenon of electric vehicle inventory buildup at dealerships as context for prior EV discussions.
City Manager Bevan referenced the Reporting of Emergency and Sole Source Purchases for August 2023 as an agenda item.
No council members had questions on the report.
Heard before · Item I.8 · Sep 19, 2023
Aug 1, 2023 · City Council · Item I.7 · first reading — Annexation of about 330.8 acres (application 5108) passed first reading 5-0, motion by Council Member Klufas, second by Vice Mayor Danko (approved minutes p. 9). The minutes (p. 8) record Council Member Pontieri asking for clarification of the utility-service requirement. No unit count was discussed.
Aug 15, 2023 · City Council · Item G.3 · second reading — Adopted on second reading as Ordinance 2023-10, 5-0 roll call, motion by Council Member Klufas, second by Vice Mayor Danko (approved minutes p. 4-5; captions 1:01:17-1:01:29). No changes since first reading; no unit count was discussed.
Aug 16, 2023 · Planning board · Item D.2 and D.3 · recommendation — PLDRB recommended approval of both. FLUM amendment (application #5109, with a site-specific policy limiting development to 850 dwelling units): 4-1, motion by Board Member Gross, second by Board Member Dodson-Lucas, Vice Chair Shank no. Rezoning (application #5107, about 375 acres to SFR-1, MFR-2 and PRS): 5-0, same mover and seconder (minutes). No video of this meeting has been found; the minutes are the only record.
Sep 19, 2023 · City Council · Item I.8 and I.9 · this meeting
Nov 7, 2023 · City Council · Item H.11 and H.12 · second reading — The land-use change was adopted as Ordinance 2023-15 with the cap set at the original 416 units, 3-1 (Vice Mayor Danko no; Council Member Klufas absent), on a motion by Council Member Pontieri seconded by Council Member Heighter (video 03:32:30, roll call 03:33:24-03:33:38). An earlier Pontieri motion to deny died 2-2, and Danko motions to approve at 750 units and to continue drew no vote. The rezoning was adopted as Ordinance 2023-16 with all MFR-2 changed to SFR-1, 4-0, motion Danko, second Pontieri (approved minutes pp. 10-12).
Nov 15, 2023 · Planning board · Item D.3 · recommendation — PLDRB approved the Cascades at Grand Landing subdivision master plan (App. 5478; 386 single-family lots on 180.47 acres, the first two phases) 7-0, motion Board Member Hilton, second Board Member Dodson-Lucas, on condition the site plan reflect the zoning council adopted Nov 7, 2023. No video; approved minutes only.
Dec 19, 2023 · City Council · Item F.3 · rehearing granted — Council agreed 3-1 to rehear the Nov 7, 2023 land-use change at the earliest possible date, on a motion by Mayor Alfin (gavel passed to Vice Mayor Danko), seconded by Council Member Klufas; Alfin, Klufas and Danko yes, Pontieri no, Heighter absent (video roll call 00:54:05-00:54:18; minutes p. 4). The applicant, for JTL Grand Landing, said the owner of the 44.3-acre hook parcel never authorized the plan change.
Jan 2, 2024 · City Council · Item F.4 · rehearing — Rehearing of the land-use change (granted Dec 19). After a motion to postpone to Jan 16 (Danko/Klufas) failed 3-2, a motion by Council Member Pontieri, seconded by Council Member Heighter, to deny the request and revert to the Nov 7, 2023 decision failed 4-1 (only Pontieri yes; Heighter voted no and afterward said she had not heard the motion properly; no revote). Council Member Klufas's amended motion, seconded by Pontieri, to remove the JTL "hook" parcel and keep the plan amendment with the site-specific 416-unit limit then passed 5-0 (video roll call 05:19:39-05:19:47; minutes pp. 12-13). The applicant had asked to remove the hook and approve 850 units. The adopted Ordinance 2024-01 (8 pp., signed, marked readopted Jan 2, 2024; obtained by records request) limits the Cascades Planning Area to 416 dwelling units on about 330.8 acres and recites the “deletion of a 44.5+/- acre parcel under separate ownership” (p. 2 of 8).
Feb 4, 2025 · City Council · Item L · Bert Harris response — Response to the developer's Bert Harris Act claim (filed Nov 6, 2024). City Attorney Duffy gave two options: uphold Ordinance 2024-01, or offer more density (an additional 219 single-family units, per the captions). Motion by Vice Mayor Pontieri, seconded by Council Member Stevens, to respond no and keep the ordinance as-is (minutes p. 12); passed 5-0 on a roll call (captions 3:31:01-3:31:14; the minutes record no tally for this motion).
Council heard the first reading of an ordinance annexing about 330.8 acres south of Flagler County Airport for the Cascades (application 5108), requested by Byrndog PCP, LLC.
Senior Planner Phong Nguyen said the land meets the statutory tests for voluntary annexation, and that city ordinances and a settlement agreement require land in the city's utility service area to annex before it can receive city utilities.
Council Member Pontieri asked whether annexation is required when utilities are requested and whether the owner could instead pay the outside-city surcharge; staff said the settlement agreement and ordinances do not allow that, and she said "the wiggle room is very small." Resident Celia Pugliese asked about utility capacity and raised flight-school noise near the airport; resident Steve Carr asked what annexation would cost the city, and Ray Tyner said infrastructure is at the developer's cost.
Mayor Alfin got consensus for staff to ask the county about changes in airport use.
The first reading passed on a voice vote.
Vote, per the approved minutes: motion to approve on first reading — Passed 5-0 (Alfin, Danko, Klufas, Pontieri, Heighter) Moved by Klufas, seconded by Danko.
Vote, per our caption record: 5-0 (motion Klufas, second Danko; Alfin, Danko, Klufas, Pontieri, Heighter yes)
The voluntary annexation of approximately 330.8 acres south of Flagler County Airport (the Cascades parcel, application 5108) received its second reading.
Staff confirmed it meets statutory contiguity and compactness requirements.
Three residents spoke: Bob Meyer and Jan Manella asked about the 44 acres in Grand Landings (staff said the 44-45-acre "hook piece" was annexed earlier and will come back with a future FLUM amendment and rezoning), and Dennis McDonald raised airport noise.
Council briefly discussed commissioning a noise study for the airport and noted airport representatives will present to council in October.
The ordinance passed 5-0 on a roll call, on a motion by Klufas and a second by Danko.
Vote, per the approved minutes: motion to be adopted on second reading — Passed 5-0 (Alfin, Danko, Klufas, Pontieri, Heighter) Moved by Klufas, seconded by Danko.
Vote, per our caption record: 5-0 (motion Klufas, second Danko; Danko, Heighter, Klufas, Pontieri, Alfin yes)
Sources: the Sep 19, 2023 agenda packet (page numbers link to the page), and PalmCoastStorylines meeting records for August 1, 2023; August 15, 2023, built from the city's agenda packets and meeting video. Summaries and votes from those meetings are generated from the captions and are unverified unless marked otherwise; the video is the record. Agenda (cover sheets) →
Heard before · Item I.9 · Sep 19, 2023
Aug 1, 2023 · City Council · Item I.7 · first reading — Annexation of about 330.8 acres (application 5108) passed first reading 5-0, motion by Council Member Klufas, second by Vice Mayor Danko (approved minutes p. 9). The minutes (p. 8) record Council Member Pontieri asking for clarification of the utility-service requirement. No unit count was discussed.
Aug 15, 2023 · City Council · Item G.3 · second reading — Adopted on second reading as Ordinance 2023-10, 5-0 roll call, motion by Council Member Klufas, second by Vice Mayor Danko (approved minutes p. 4-5; captions 1:01:17-1:01:29). No changes since first reading; no unit count was discussed.
Aug 16, 2023 · Planning board · Item D.2 and D.3 · recommendation — PLDRB recommended approval of both. FLUM amendment (application #5109, with a site-specific policy limiting development to 850 dwelling units): 4-1, motion by Board Member Gross, second by Board Member Dodson-Lucas, Vice Chair Shank no. Rezoning (application #5107, about 375 acres to SFR-1, MFR-2 and PRS): 5-0, same mover and seconder (minutes). No video of this meeting has been found; the minutes are the only record.
Sep 19, 2023 · City Council · Item I.8 and I.9 · this meeting
Nov 7, 2023 · City Council · Item H.11 and H.12 · second reading — The land-use change was adopted as Ordinance 2023-15 with the cap set at the original 416 units, 3-1 (Vice Mayor Danko no; Council Member Klufas absent), on a motion by Council Member Pontieri seconded by Council Member Heighter (video 03:32:30, roll call 03:33:24-03:33:38). An earlier Pontieri motion to deny died 2-2, and Danko motions to approve at 750 units and to continue drew no vote. The rezoning was adopted as Ordinance 2023-16 with all MFR-2 changed to SFR-1, 4-0, motion Danko, second Pontieri (approved minutes pp. 10-12).
Nov 15, 2023 · Planning board · Item D.3 · recommendation — PLDRB approved the Cascades at Grand Landing subdivision master plan (App. 5478; 386 single-family lots on 180.47 acres, the first two phases) 7-0, motion Board Member Hilton, second Board Member Dodson-Lucas, on condition the site plan reflect the zoning council adopted Nov 7, 2023. No video; approved minutes only.
Dec 19, 2023 · City Council · Item F.3 · rehearing granted — Council agreed 3-1 to rehear the Nov 7, 2023 land-use change at the earliest possible date, on a motion by Mayor Alfin (gavel passed to Vice Mayor Danko), seconded by Council Member Klufas; Alfin, Klufas and Danko yes, Pontieri no, Heighter absent (video roll call 00:54:05-00:54:18; minutes p. 4). The applicant, for JTL Grand Landing, said the owner of the 44.3-acre hook parcel never authorized the plan change.
Jan 2, 2024 · City Council · Item F.4 · rehearing — Rehearing of the land-use change (granted Dec 19). After a motion to postpone to Jan 16 (Danko/Klufas) failed 3-2, a motion by Council Member Pontieri, seconded by Council Member Heighter, to deny the request and revert to the Nov 7, 2023 decision failed 4-1 (only Pontieri yes; Heighter voted no and afterward said she had not heard the motion properly; no revote). Council Member Klufas's amended motion, seconded by Pontieri, to remove the JTL "hook" parcel and keep the plan amendment with the site-specific 416-unit limit then passed 5-0 (video roll call 05:19:39-05:19:47; minutes pp. 12-13). The applicant had asked to remove the hook and approve 850 units. The adopted Ordinance 2024-01 (8 pp., signed, marked readopted Jan 2, 2024; obtained by records request) limits the Cascades Planning Area to 416 dwelling units on about 330.8 acres and recites the “deletion of a 44.5+/- acre parcel under separate ownership” (p. 2 of 8).
Feb 4, 2025 · City Council · Item L · Bert Harris response — Response to the developer's Bert Harris Act claim (filed Nov 6, 2024). City Attorney Duffy gave two options: uphold Ordinance 2024-01, or offer more density (an additional 219 single-family units, per the captions). Motion by Vice Mayor Pontieri, seconded by Council Member Stevens, to respond no and keep the ordinance as-is (minutes p. 12); passed 5-0 on a roll call (captions 3:31:01-3:31:14; the minutes record no tally for this motion).
Council heard the first reading of an ordinance annexing about 330.8 acres south of Flagler County Airport for the Cascades (application 5108), requested by Byrndog PCP, LLC.
Senior Planner Phong Nguyen said the land meets the statutory tests for voluntary annexation, and that city ordinances and a settlement agreement require land in the city's utility service area to annex before it can receive city utilities.
Council Member Pontieri asked whether annexation is required when utilities are requested and whether the owner could instead pay the outside-city surcharge; staff said the settlement agreement and ordinances do not allow that, and she said "the wiggle room is very small." Resident Celia Pugliese asked about utility capacity and raised flight-school noise near the airport; resident Steve Carr asked what annexation would cost the city, and Ray Tyner said infrastructure is at the developer's cost.
Mayor Alfin got consensus for staff to ask the county about changes in airport use.
The first reading passed on a voice vote.
Vote, per the approved minutes: motion to approve on first reading — Passed 5-0 (Alfin, Danko, Klufas, Pontieri, Heighter) Moved by Klufas, seconded by Danko.
Vote, per our caption record: 5-0 (motion Klufas, second Danko; Alfin, Danko, Klufas, Pontieri, Heighter yes)
The voluntary annexation of approximately 330.8 acres south of Flagler County Airport (the Cascades parcel, application 5108) received its second reading.
Staff confirmed it meets statutory contiguity and compactness requirements.
Three residents spoke: Bob Meyer and Jan Manella asked about the 44 acres in Grand Landings (staff said the 44-45-acre "hook piece" was annexed earlier and will come back with a future FLUM amendment and rezoning), and Dennis McDonald raised airport noise.
Council briefly discussed commissioning a noise study for the airport and noted airport representatives will present to council in October.
The ordinance passed 5-0 on a roll call, on a motion by Klufas and a second by Danko.
Vote, per the approved minutes: motion to be adopted on second reading — Passed 5-0 (Alfin, Danko, Klufas, Pontieri, Heighter) Moved by Klufas, seconded by Danko.
Vote, per our caption record: 5-0 (motion Klufas, second Danko; Danko, Heighter, Klufas, Pontieri, Alfin yes)
Sources: the Sep 19, 2023 agenda packet (page numbers link to the page), and PalmCoastStorylines meeting records for August 1, 2023; August 15, 2023, built from the city's agenda packets and meeting video. Summaries and votes from those meetings are generated from the captions and are unverified unless marked otherwise; the video is the record. Agenda (cover sheets) →
Speaker, representing Polo Club West HOA, asked to review the voluntary agreement between the developer and HOA before it was used as a reason to annex.
Speaker stated water and sewer would be provided with or without annexation, argued the developer's goal is to rezone from the existing PUD to single-family residential to eliminate PUD requirements including minimum building sizes, vegetative buffers, and amenity centers.
Requested more time and more concrete concessions before annexation proceeds.
Speaker, a Polo Club West property owner at 36 Steeplechase, stated the annexation would erase a complex PUD that included unified community design, vegetative buffering, recreational areas, and minimum lot and home sizes.
Noted residents invested based on the existing PUD at their front entrance.
Reported a town hall was held with good discussions but promised conceptual drawings of buffers had not been delivered.
Requested the council either delay annexation until more commitments are in writing or direct staff to ensure specific deliverables are addressed.
Speaker, a Polo Club West resident at 67 Steeplechase, stated that minutes from the developer's community meeting contained inaccurate and incomplete information.
Requested more time before annexation to ensure developer commitments are followed through, and asked that additional meetings be held to define expectations for the shared community boundary.